Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
Title: Ideología y selección lingüística en los textos históricos: las traducciones españolas de "History of the Conquest of Mexico" de W.H. Prescott
Other Titles: Ideology and language selection in historical texts: The Spanish translation of History of the Conquest of Mexico by W.H. Prescott
Authors: Díaz Peralta, Marina 
Piñero Piñero, María De Gracia 
García Domínguez, María Jesús 
UNESCO Clasification: 57 Lingüística
570112 Traducción
Issue Date: 2008
Journal: Babel 
Abstract: It is often stated that an original text may be translated in as many different ways as translators work on it, and that translators imbue their work, consciously or unconsciously, with their mental and cultural perspective. This idea of translation as an ideological activity leads us to view the target text as the result of a continuous process of selection at all levels of language that reveals both the power and the responsibility of the translator. We believe that historical texts are particularly vulnerable to ideological manipulation, and that they therefore constitute valuable material in studies aimed at identifying the intervention of the translator. This article presents a contrastive analysis of two translation into Spanish of History of the Conquest of the Conqueror, Hernando Cortés (1843), written by William H. Prescott, one of the great Anglo-american historians to have worked on the Hispanic world. His books on the Spanish colonial period invariably present the conquerors' point of view. The translations studied were both published in 1844, and this concurrence in time underlines the value of our findings as the divergences identified are not attributable to time-specific ideological differences. Thus, we can see that one of the translators voluntarily mirrors the voice of the author of the original text and adopts his vision of the conquest of Mexico, while the other translator takes an appreciably different view, offering a version of the conquest that is closer to the viewpoint of the conquered.
ISSN: 0521-9744
DOI: 10.1075/babel.54.3.03dia
Source: Babel [ISSN 0521-9744], v. 54(3), p. 251-267
Appears in Collections:Reseña
Show full item record


checked on Feb 28, 2021

Page view(s)

checked on Feb 22, 2021

Google ScholarTM




Export metadata

Items in accedaCRIS are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved, unless otherwise indicated.