Disentangling upwelling: how light and nutrient supply shape primary producers and stoichiometry in the Humboldt upwelling system

Abstract

The Humboldt upwelling system (HUS) is known for its extraordinary productivity due to wind-driven upwelling of nutrient-rich deep water, resulting in the highest fish catches per unit area worldwide. However, contrary to other Eastern boundary upwelling systems, upwelling intensity is highest in winter, while primary productivity reaches its peak during the summer months. Our current understanding of the counterintuitive relationship between upwelling intensity and productivity is insufficient to predict the consequences of climate change on this ecosystem. To elucidate the drivers of the upwelling-productivity relationship in the HUS, we tested the hypothesis that low light availability limits primary productivity in winter despite strong upwelling intensity supplying plenty of nutrients into the surface layer, while light availability in the shallower mixed layer in summer enables an effective use of the upwelled nutrients. To disentangle the interactive effects of light and nutrients on primary production and carbon cycling, we enclosed natural plankton communities off the coast of Callao (Peru) during a 35-day mesocosm experiment by recreating summer-time high light and winter-time low light conditions under different upwelling intensities (0 %, 15 %, 30 %, 45 % and 60 %). Primary productivity and phytoplankton biomass scaled with both nitrate and light availability. Comparing the same upwelling intensity at different light levels, our data confirmed the hypothesis that light limitation due to deepening of the mixed layer is a key driver for the out-of-phase observations in primary productivity in the Humboldt upwelling system. Under light limiting conditions phytoplankton had low POC:Chla ratios indicating photoacclimation and low POC:PON ratios indicating light limitation of nitrate uptake which leads to increased food quality for grazers in winter. Our study indicates that small seasonal changes in phytoplankton biomass (estimated using Chla) might hide larger changes in primary productivity (carbon uptake), and highlights the importance of combining satellite studies with in situ observations and experimental studies to predict the fate of upwelling systems in a changing ocean. Increased stratification caused by global warming in upwelling systems such as the HUS would lead to less phytoplankton biomass with higher POC:Chla and POC:PON ratios. This phytoplankton community would have lower food quality for grazers and might lead to a decline in the transfer to higher trophic levels, but at the same time might lead to increased CO2 drawdown in an otherwise CO2 emitting ecosystem. Understanding the unique relationship between upwelling intensity and productivity in the HUS contributes to predicting the reaction of this valuable ecosystem for fisheries to the impacts of climate change.